All articles

Mythbuster

If You Want to Build Muscle, You Must Strictly Avoid Plant Fats / Prefer Animal Fats. — Grow Fit Academy Mythbuster: If You Want to Build Muscle, You Must Strictly Avoid Plant Fats / Prefer Animal Fats. Protein source and amino acid profile (especially leucine content) determine muscle growth. The fatty acid profile of the diet does influence cardiovascular health, but with adequate intake of essential fatty acids it does not differ in direct anabolism for muscle tissue. The myth persists because it conflates two things: **protein quality** (relevant for muscle building) and **fatty acid profile** (relevant for cardiovascular health). For muscle building, what matters first and foremost is that you eat enough protein with sufficient leucine and all essential amino acids — the fat source is secondary. More important than "plant vs. animal" is the **overall balance**: calories, protein, training stimulus, and recovery. Both variants provide sufficient essential fatty acids (omega-3/omega-6) and enough protein. What matters is the **amount and distribution of protein** throughout the day (e.g., 3–5 portions of 0.3–0.4 g/kg each). This shows you: the fat source changes, the protein target stays constant — and that is exactly what matters for muscle building. **Ideal:** Hit your protein target daily, choose a variety of fat sources (don't forget omega-3), progressively increase the training stimulus. **Good enough:** One protein source per meal, fat according to appetite, 3–4 training sessions per week. **First step:** Today, switch one meal to a clear protein source and consciously choose the fat source — plant or animal, entirely according to preference. The myth that building muscle necessarily requires animal fats and forbids plant fats is false based on evidence: for muscle growth, what counts is the amino acid profile (especially leucine) and total protein amount, not the fat source. Fatty acid profiles influence cardiovascular health, but not directly muscle anabolism.

1 January 20184 min readGrow Fit Academy

Summary

The myth that building muscle necessarily requires animal fats and forbids plant fats is false based on evidence: for muscle growth, what counts is the amino acid profile (especially leucine) and total protein amount, not the fat source. Fatty acid profiles influence cardiovascular health, but not directly muscle anabolism.

Primary source

Read the original source

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30167963/

Mythbuster: If You Want to Build Muscle, You Must Strictly Avoid Plant Fats / Prefer Animal Fats.

The Myth

If you want to build muscle, you must strictly avoid plant fats / prefer animal fats.

What the Evidence Says

Protein source and amino acid profile (especially leucine content) determine muscle growth. The fatty acid profile of the diet does influence cardiovascular health, but with adequate intake of essential fatty acids it does not differ in direct anabolism for muscle tissue.

Practice: Concrete Implementation

The myth persists because it conflates two things: protein quality (relevant for muscle building) and fatty acid profile (relevant for cardiovascular health). For muscle building, what matters first and foremost is that you eat enough protein with sufficient leucine and all essential amino acids — the fat source is secondary. More important than "plant vs. animal" is the overall balance: calories, protein, training stimulus, and recovery.

Example A — Weekly Plan (Distributing Fat Sources Sensibly)

Meal "Animal Fats Emphasized" Variant "Plant Fats Emphasized" Variant
Breakfast Scrambled eggs with butter, whole-grain bread Oatmeal with nuts, flaxseed, soy yogurt
Lunch Chicken, rice, olive-oil vegetables Lentil dal, rice, olive-oil vegetables
Snack Quark, walnuts Soy yogurt, walnuts
Dinner Salmon, potatoes, salad with canola oil Tofu, potatoes, salad with canola oil
Daily protein ~1.6–2.2 g/kg body weight ~1.6–2.2 g/kg body weight

Both variants provide sufficient essential fatty acids (omega-3/omega-6) and enough protein. What matters is the amount and distribution of protein throughout the day (e.g., 3–5 portions of 0.3–0.4 g/kg each).

Example B — Execution & Coaching Cues

  • Plan protein first: Define a clear protein source for each meal (meat, fish, egg, dairy products, soy, legumes, protein isolates).
  • Keep leucine in mind: Combine plant sources (e.g., rice + beans, soy + grains) to improve the amino acid profile.
  • Don't demonize fat: Fat is calorie-dense — dose it consciously during a bulking phase, and don't cut it too much during a diet (hormone balance).
  • Cue: "Protein per meal, fat according to taste and tolerance."
  • Cue: "Don't optimize the fat source, hit the protein amount."

Example C — Microcycle (7 Days, Fat Focus)

Day Fat Source in Focus Protein Target
1 Olive oil, nuts 1.8 g/kg
2 Salmon (omega-3) 1.8 g/kg
3 Canola oil, avocado 1.8 g/kg
4 Eggs, butter 1.8 g/kg
5 Flaxseed, walnuts 1.8 g/kg
6 Mixed diet 1.8 g/kg
7 Mixed diet 1.8 g/kg

This shows you: the fat source changes, the protein target stays constant — and that is exactly what matters for muscle building.

Ideal: Hit your protein target daily, choose a variety of fat sources (don't forget omega-3), progressively increase the training stimulus.

Good enough: One protein source per meal, fat according to appetite, 3–4 training sessions per week.

First step: Today, switch one meal to a clear protein source and consciously choose the fat source — plant or animal, entirely according to preference.

Continue at the source

Read the original source

FAQ

Are animal fats really better than plant fats for building muscle?

No. For muscle building, protein quality (amino acid profile, leucine content) and total protein amount are decisive. The fat source has no direct anabolic advantage as long as essential fatty acids are supplied in sufficient amounts.

As a vegan, do I need to eat more protein to build muscle?

Plant proteins often have a somewhat less favorable amino acid profile and lower digestibility. Therefore, a somewhat higher total protein amount (e.g., 1.8–2.2 g/kg) and combining different sources can be sensible to cover enough leucine and all essential amino acids.

Which fats should I prefer when building muscle?

A balanced mix: unsaturated fatty acids (olive oil, canola oil, nuts, avocado) and omega-3 sources (salmon, flaxseed, walnuts) for health, plus saturated fats in moderation. What matters is the overall calorie and protein balance, not the exclusive fat source.

Share